PHIL 342  Philosophy of Mind
PHIL 611 Seminar in Metphysics: Mind and Matter
Fall 2006

Instructor
Instructor
Dr. Robert Barnard
Contact
Email: rwbjr@olemiss.edu -- Phone: 662 915 7020
Office Hours (Updated 8/27/03)
Office: MBHC 317, Hours:  TBA
Course Description

This course is designed to offer a deep introduction into issues a problems arising in contemporary Philosophy of Mind. Topics considered will include: theories of the mind/brain, qualia, content, and intentionality. The aim of this course is to increase the student's facility in this area of philosophy. This particular incarnation of the class will focus on the metaphysical questions prompted by reflection philosophical upon the mind.

Successful undergraduate students in this course:

  • Demonstrate the ability to present and explain basic philosophical positions regarding the nature of mind.
  • Demonstrate the ability to present and explain objections to basic philosophical positions regarding the nature of mind.
  • Understand the general historical, scientific, and intellectual contexts in which these views emerge and develop.
  • Comprehend the general relationship between basic philosophical positions regarding the nature of mind and related discussions in other areas of philosophy.

Successful graduate students in this course:

  • Demonstrate the ability to clearly and precisely present and explain significant philosophical positions regarding the nature of mind.
  • Demonstrate the ability to clearly and precisely present and explain objections to significant philosophical positions regarding the nature of mind, and possibly develop original criticisms of these views.
  • Understand in detail the historical, scientific, and intellectual contexts in which these views emerge and develop.
  • Comprehend in detail the relationship between significant philosophical positions regarding the nature of mind and related discussions in other areas of philosophy.
Texts

This course has several required texts:
1) Paul Chrurchland, Matter and Consciousness, Revised Edition MIT 0262530740[MC]
2) Patricia Churchland Brain-Wise MIT 026253200X [BW]
3) Valentino Braitenberg, Vehicles MIT 0262521121 [V]
4) David Chalmers the Conscious Mind Oxford 0195105532 [CM]
5) Tom Polger Natural Minds MIT 0262162210 [NM]

Recommended (but not ordered)
Chalmers, ed. Philosophy of Mind: Classical and Contemporary Readings, Oxford
Guttenplan, ed. A Companion to Philosophy of Mind, Blackwell
Heil, J. Philosophy of Mind: A Contemporary Introduction, Routledge


Requirements and Evaluation

1) Attendance and Participation  (UG 20% / G 15%)
All students are expected to attend all class meetings and to prepare and participate in a manner commensurate with their class standing.  However, all students should be prepared to discuss the readings.  The course is intended to be a seminar not a lecture course.  Participation and preparation are essential to the success of the course. Note on:

Academic Integrity
I require that every student know and observe all rules and policies related to academic conduct and work, especially plagiarism. Academic integrity is essential to all the values upon which the university is founded. All students must therefore embody academic honesty in all aspects of their work. A student with a documented case of plagairism or academic cheating in an honors course will receive the grade of F for the course. Students should consult the M-BOOK for detailed descriptions of academic cheating and plagiarism. Neither I, nor the M-Book, distinguish between intentional and unintentional violations, nor do I distinguish degrees of severity of violation.
Academic writing is a balance between the use of sources and their integration in works of original exposition, exegesis, and analysis. Failure to conform to relevant and prevailing standards of academic integrity, especially as involve class decorum and plagiarism will result in significant penalties. If you are unclear about these standards you may consult the M-Book, various on-line sources, or the Writing Center. (policy is modeled on that of the SMBHC)


2) Weekly Blurbs  (UG 20% / G 10%)
All students will submit weekly 'blurbs' on the readings.  Blurbs are due no later than 12 noon on the day before class.  Blurbs will be emailed to the class distribution list <drbob@yahoogroups.com>.  Blurbs can be questions about the reading or raise objections to the readings.  Undergrads should try to blurb about 1/2 of a page (minimum), Graduate students should strive for 3/4 of a page(minimum). Blurbing is a good way to keep track of questions you want to raise in class or issues you might write about in a seminar paper.

3)  Short Critiques  (UG 10% / G 40%)
Graduate students must submit 3 short critical reviews.  Critical reviews are 2-3 pp long (no longer).  I will identify 2-5 passages from the text and the student will choose one passage and prepare a review which a) summarizes the argument or main points in the passage and b) raises a brief critical or interpretive point.  The best two critical reviews will be counted toward your final grade. Failure to submit a critique will result in a zero being recorded for the computation of the final grade. A zero for non-submission will be counted as one of your 'best' scores.

Undergraduate students will submit 1 short critique.

4) Midterm Exam (UG 20%)
Undergraduate students will complete a midterm examination.

5) Paper / Final Exam

a) Undergraduate Students
 (30%)
Undergraduates may choose between preparing a take-home cumulative final exam or writing a 10-12 pp. seminar paper on an approved topic.

b) Graduate Students
 (40%)

Graduate students are required to prepare a 12-15 pp. seminar paper on an approved topic.

Note: The best way to fail the course is to remain silent, never ask questions, fail to submit work, miss exams, sleep through class, not turn in your journals/blurbs, and not do the reading. Philosophy is an ongoing interactive activity.
Fine Print
All students are expected to conform to the relevant and prevailing standards of academic conduct, both explicit and implied. The instructor reserves the right to modify the contents of this syllabus at his sole discretion. The student is responsible for remaining informed of any changes. Attendance and/or submission of work in this course shall be understood to constitute evidence of both acceptance and understanding of course requirements and expectations as outlined in this or any subsequent version of the course syllabus. Late work will not be accepted unless prior arrangement has been made with the instructor. No technology related excuses will be accepted unless there is a widespread event (e.g. the whole campus network collapses, massive solar flare activity, or Alien invasion, etc.) You must receive a C or better in order to count this class toward a major or minor in philosophy.

 Proposed Reading Schedule


Week
Date
Reading
Topic(s)
1
23 Aug
[MC] pp. 1-51 Introduction to Mind-Body problem
2
30 Aug
[MC] pp. 51-99 Methodological Approaches to the MBP
3
6 Sep
[V] pp. 1-94 What kind of critter is a human with a mind?
4
(sc1 due)
13 Sep
[BW] pp. 1-34 [V] pp. 95-145 [MC] pp. 123-146 Brains!
5
20 Sep
[BW] pp. 127-200 Consciousness and Brains
6
27 Sep
[CM] pp. 1-92; Horgan Paper [GS only] Consciousness and Supervenience
7
(sc2 due)
4 Oct
[CM] pp. 93-172 Consciousness and (non-)Reduction
8
UG Midterm
11 Oct
[CM] pp. 172-247 Qualia// UG Midterm Due
9
18 Oct
[CM] pp. 247-309 More Qualia and Information
10
25 Oct
[NM] pp. 1-70 Minds, Realization, Identity
sc3 Due

30 Oct
(sc3 due) SC 3 due to me in hard copy by 12:00 Noon
11
1 Nov
NO CLASS Catch up on reading//work on term paper//get ready for final exam.
12
8 Nov
[NM] pp. 71-138 A lot about Functionalism
13
15 Nov
[NM] pp. 139-212 Realization Issues
Holiday
22 Nov
None Holiday
14 29 Nov
[NM] pp. 213-246 Minds and People
EXAM     Final Exams/Papers Due in my office by 5pm Wednesday of Exam Week